GTA最大的亲子生活资讯服务平台
Notifications
Clear all
Topic starter
04/09/2025 11:19 下午
My 4th grader used to hate talking about ELA—seriously. He’s fine with everyday English (we’re in an all-English household, so that checks out), but when it came to actual ELA work? Total struggle. Reading passages felt like wading through mud, and writing essays? Forget it—he’d stare at a blank page for 30 minutes just to eke out 5 basic sentences. Last month, his class had to share their "favorite picture book character," and he froze up. All he could say was, "He’s cool," over and over. No details, no personality—just plain, boring stuff.
As a mom, I wasn’t asking for a literary genius, but c’mon—some simple descriptive phrases would’ve been nice! I tried every offline class in our neighborhood first, then gave Huiya (that AI-based program everyone was talking about) a shot for a month. Nothing stuck. I even thought, Maybe this is as good as it gets—I was this close to giving up on his writing. Then we tried Wukong International ELA, and… wow. Finally, I saw him care about English. Let me break it down for any other parents out there who’s been there—hopefully this saves you some time (and stress!).
Offline Classes: Fun for Some, a Waste for Us
Everyone kept saying, "Offline classes have that real English vibe—your kid’ll have to speak up!" So I signed him up for a small class (15 kids) near our house. Three weeks in, I knew it was a miss.
The teacher would read picture books with the group, but she moved so fast. When they did The Little Red Hen, the top kids were retelling the whole story while my son was still tripping over "wheat." He wanted to ask for help, but he’s shy—afraid the other kids would laugh. So he just pretended to follow along, head down, not saying a word.
Writing was even worse. Every week, the prompt was the same: "My Pet" or "My Weekend." The teacher only marked spelling mistakes—never taught him how to add details. He’d write, "I have a cat. It’s cute." When I asked, "What makes her cute? Does she curl up on your lap? Chase string?" He’d shrug and say, "I don’t know how to say that in English." No follow-up, no practice—just "here’s your paper, see you next week." By week 4, he was begging me, "Can we skip ELA? It’s so boring."
Huiya: Cool AI, But No Real Learning
Next up was Huiya. I heard their AI could correct pronunciation and grammar in real time—sounded perfect for a kid who hates being embarrassed in class. The flexibility was great (no rushing to after-school classes!), and the AI was smart: when he mispronounced "tomorrow," it popped up with a video of someone saying it right; when he forgot a comma, it highlighted the spot. But after 6 weeks? Still no progress.
First, the lessons were all over the place. One day they’d do reading comprehension, the next poetry (poetry!), then suddenly speaking drills. No flow at all. He learned a few writing tricks on Monday, then by Wednesday they were talking about fable morals—and he’d already forgotten what he’d learned. It was like building a Lego set and then taking it apart before it was done.
Worse, it didn’t line up with what he’s learning at school. His teacher focuses a lot on "finding supporting details" (you know, Common Core stuff), but Huiya only taught him to "find the main idea." So when he had a test on that, he blanked—again. And the AI? It’s great at correcting mistakes, but it can’t guide. Once, after reading a story, the AI asked, "Do you like the main character?" He said, "I don’t know," and… that was it. No follow-up, no "Why do you think that?" Just silence. No help with critical thinking—total dealbreaker.
Wukong International ELA: The First Time He Got Excited About ELA
A mom in my school’s parent group mentioned Wukong—said it’s designed for overseas kids, aligned with school standards. I signed him up for a trial, fully expecting another letdown. But when he came out of the class? He ran to me, grinning: "Mom! We made up an ending for a mouse story—and I got to share it with the class!" I almost cried.
① Small, Live Classes = No More Hiding
Wukong’s classes are small—6 to 8 kids max, live with a real teacher. No recorded videos, no robots. When they talked about "character traits" last week, the teacher pulled up a clip from Charlotte's Web (his favorite movie!) and asked, "Is Wilbur brave or scared?" He didn’t answer at first, but the teacher didn’t rush him. She said, "Look—when he first met Charlotte, did he run away? What about later, when he had to save the farm?" Slow, gentle prompts. Finally, he raised his hand: "He was scared first, but then he tried. That’s brave." I was so proud—I’d never heard him talk about characters like that before.
Even reading time is different. The teacher doesn’t just read to them—she asks, "What do you think will happen next?" Last week, they read a story about a lost bird, and he yelled out, "Maybe the cat will help her find home!" He never would’ve done that in the offline class.
② They Teach Him to Think, Not Just Repeat
Writing used to be his worst subject—now? He actually asks to practice. The teachers use mind maps, which is game-changing. When he wrote about "My Weekend" last month, the teacher helped him draw a timeline: "Morning at the park—what did you see? Smell? Feel?" He listed "cherry blossoms, pigeons, warm sun." Then she showed him how to turn that into a sentence: "Walking in the park, I smelled sweet cherry blossoms and felt the sun on my cheeks."
He ran to show me that sentence—so proud. "Mom, it’s like a story now!" Before, he thought writing was just listing facts. Now he gets that it’s about sharing a moment.
③ It’s Actually Aligned with School (Thank Goodness!)
This is the big one for me. Wukong’s lessons match what he’s learning in class—Common Core and all. Last month, his teacher was drilling "supporting details," and Wukong did the same thing—just in a more fun way. The teacher gave them a passage about pandas, then had them use highlighters (virtual ones, since it’s online) to mark facts that back up "pandas love bamboo."
A week later, he had a quiz at school—and he aced that section! He came home and said, "I used the trick from Wukong! It was easy!" Finally—something that actually helps with his homework, not just feels like extra work.
④ After-Class Help That Doesn’t Make Me Panic
I don’t know about you, but I’m not an ELA teacher. When he has homework questions, I usually end up Googling "how to teach supporting details to a 10-year-old" at 8 PM. Wukong fixes that.
After every class, we get a detailed report: "He nailed character analysis today, but needs more practice with ‘because’ sentences." They even send a progress chart for reading, writing, and speaking—so I know exactly where he’s at. And if he gets stuck on homework? He can send a photo to his tutor, who gets back to him in 10 minutes—no waiting. Last week, he didn’t know how to end a story, and the tutor asked, "What if the main character didn’t find his toy—would he ask a friend for help, or try again tomorrow?" He thought about it, then wrote the ending himself. No hand-holding—just the push he needed.
Now? He Talks About ELA Voluntarily
It’s been 4 months, and the change is crazy. He used to hide his ELA worksheets; now he brings them to me to read. Last night, he finished a picture book and said, "Mom, the main character is just like Wilbur—he’s brave even when he’s scared!" He’s using descriptive words, asking questions about stories, and even writing little "stories" about his cat in his free time.
Offline classes were too one-size-fits-all, Huiya was too robotic—but Wukong gets it. They know overseas kids need to learn ELA and actually enjoy it, not just check a box.
A Quick Tip for Other Parents
If you try the Wukong trial? Have your kid bring a recent ELA worksheet or a story they struggled with. After our trial, the teacher looked at his "favorite character" assignment from school and gave him specific tips on adding details. She even recommended 3 picture books at his level—ones he actually wanted to read. It’s the little things that make a difference.
If you’ve tried 100 things and nothing works, give Wukong a shot. And if you do—come back and share your experience! We’re all in this together, right?
ELA Program Comparison Chart
|
Program
|
Format
|
Key Features
|
Age Range
|
Kid’s Engagement (Stars)
|
|
Local Offline Classes
|
In-person (12-15 kids)
|
English atmosphere, rigid pace, no follow-up
|
6-16
|
⭐ (Avoids participation)
|
|
Huiya
|
Online AI-led
|
Pronunciation/grammar checks, disorganized curriculum
|
5-18
|
⭐⭐ (Complies but doesn’t engage)
|
|
Wukong International ELA
|
Live online (6-8 kids)
|
School-aligned, interactive, guided thinking, after-class support
|
4-15
|
⭐⭐⭐ (Participates actively, asks to practice)
|
Note: Engagement stars based on my son’s experience and feedback from 3 other parents in our school community. Tuition varies by region (we’re in the US), so check their website for latest rates!
社交媒体
关注我们
